Ontario housing market is raising red flags – Financial Post

6 minutes, 45 seconds Read

Market has deteriorated to levels not seen since the financial crisis and it could get worse, says economist

Article content

Article content

Ontario’s housing market is raising red flags.

Buy/sell, rent/lease residential &
commercials real estate properties.

The market hasn’t been this loose since the 2008 financial crisis and there is risk the sales-to-new-listings ratio could drop as low as in the 1990s meltdown when prices plunged more than 30 per cent, says a new study from Toronto-Dominion Bank.

This October the province’s sales-to-new-listings ratio dropped to its lowest level since the financial crisis.

Advertisement 2

Story continues below

Article content

The concern is if higher interest rates further dampen demand the ratio will slip to levels not seen since the deep housing market downturn in the late 1980s to mid-1990s, said TD economist Rishi Sondhi.

Sales-to-new-listings ratios measure supply and demand in housing markets and help predict prices. A ratio under 40 per cent means a buyer’s market where new listings exceed sales, between 40 and 60 per cent is a balanced market and over 60 per cent, where demand outstrips supply, is a seller’s market.

housing market
TD Economics

During the late 1980s and early 1990s, home prices plunged by 32 per cent across Ontario, falling 38 per cent in the Greater Toronto area.

“Ontario’s ratio approaching where it was during these depths certainly raises our eyebrows and warrants closer attention,” said Sondhi.

What’s remarkable is normally it would take a deep recession to get the ratio to this level, he said.

A comparison of the two downturns offers reasons to believe such an outcome can be avoided, said Sondhi.

On a per capita basis, sales today are already at the lows seen in the 1990s, but listings are about 20 per cent lower than they were then.

Article content

Advertisement 3

Story continues below

Article content

The economic backdrop is also better. From March 1990 to May 1992, Canada was in a deep recession, brought on by high interest rates and fiscal belt-tightening, among other forces. Ontario GDP and employment dropped 6 per cent peak to trough.

TD expects Ontario’s economy will stagnate next year but not fall into recession, with only a mild dip in employment.

Interest rates were also more punishing back then. From February 1989 to May of 1990 the Bank of Canada interest rate rose by about 240 basis points from 11.7 per cent to 14.1.

Today many economists think rates have hit their peak at 5 per cent and the central bank will begin cutting by the second quarter of next year.

The major wildcard, Sondhi said, is investor activity. The ’90s downturn was preceded by a surge in housing speculation that inflated a real estate bubble. When the economy spiralled into recession, homebuilders were left with an inventory overhang that pushed prices down further.

High investor activity is present today, accounting for 30 per cent of home purchases nationally in the first quarter, a high in records going back to 2014.

Advertisement 4

Story continues below

Article content

A lack of data makes a direct comparison impossible, Sondhi said, but “anecdotal information is troubling.”

“We do know that higher interest rates have brought difficulties to the pre-construction market during this cycle by making it more tough for buyers to close on properties they’ve previously purchased,” he said.

Even though a downturn of the magnitude of the 1990s is unlikely, Ontario home prices could fall another 10 per cent by mid 2024 as higher borrowing costs sap demand and more supply comes on the market as homeowners buckle under the strain.

“Homeowners will continue to face this pressure through at least 2025/26, when those that took out mortgages at ultra-cheap rates face a notable payment shock,” said Sondhi.


Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox.

Moody’s Analytics

When interest rates rise, something’s got to give.

Moody’s Analytics examined delinquency rates across different types of loans to determine how Canadians were prioritizing their payments.

Advertisement 5

Story continues below

Article content

Paying the mortgage appears to come first with delinquencies below their historical average and the share of overdue payments only a third of what they were after the financial crisis. Credit card delinquencies are also below average as Canadians cut back on this type of borrowing.

Bottom of the list is auto loan repayments. Over the past three months, delinquency rates have surpassed pre-pandemic levels and deviated further above their historical average than any other credit category, said Moody’s.

This isn’t peanuts either, as higher prices for vehicles and steeper borrowing costs have boosted the size of auto loans.

  • Shopify Inc. holds an investor day in New York. The e-commerce company’s clients hit a record US$9.3 billion in sales over Black Friday and Cyber Monday weekend, a 24 per cent increase from last year.
  • Today’s Data: U.S. ISM Services PMI for November
  • Earnings: Autozone, J M Smucker

Get all of today’s top breaking stories as they happen with the Financial Post’s live news blog, highlighting the business headlines you need to know at a glance.

Stock market chart December 5, 2023

Advertisement 6

Story continues below

Article content

Fans of The Office will know Dunder Mifflin Paper Co. Inc. and why its culture is one to be avoided, but portfolio manager Igor Bekker says investors should be paying attention to corporate culture when selecting stocks, too, since it shapes the balance of happiness between employees, customers and stakeholders, which informs long-term value creation. Find out more at FP Investing 

Related Stories

  1. Housing market conditions are loosening across the country, giving buyers' more bargaining power.

    Is your town in a buyer’s or seller’s housing market?

  2. none

    Canadians brace for mortgage renewal cliff

Today’s Posthaste was written by Pamela Heaven, @pamheaven, with additional reporting from The Canadian Press, Thomson Reuters and Bloomberg.

Have a story idea, pitch, embargoed report, or a suggestion for this newsletter? Email us at [email protected], or hit reply to send us a note.

Bookmark our website and support our journalism: Don’t miss the business news you need to know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and sign up for our newsletters here.

Article content


Join the Conversation

This Week in Flyers

This post was originally published on 3rd party site mentioned on the title of this site

Similar Posts

    Your Interest
    Your Interest List is emptyReturn to Buying